Rechtsprechung / EGMR / Ausschuss / 2024
EGMR Urteil vom 18.07.2024 – 55668/19
Ausschuss · ECLI:CE:ECHR:2024:0718JUD005566819
EuroparechtEU / InternationalVolltext
FIRST SECTION CASE OF ŽIVALJEVIĆ AND OTHERS v. MONTENEGRO (Application no. 55668/19) JUDGMENT This version was rectified on 17 October 2024 under Rule 81 of the Rules of Court. STRASBOURG 18 July 2024 This judgment is final but it may be subject to editorial revision. In the case of Živaljević and Others v. Montenegro, The European Court of Human Rights (First Section), sitting as a Committee composed of: Péter Paczolay , President , Gilberto Felici, Raffaele Sabato , judges , and Viktoriya Maradudina, Deputy Section Registrar, Having deliberated in private on 27 June 2024, Delivers the following judgment, which was adopted on that date: PROCEDURE 1. The case originated in an application against Montenegro lodged with the Court under Article 34 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (“the Convention”) on 9 October 2019. 2. The applicants were represented by Mr Lj. Marković, a lawyer practising in Podgorica. 3. The Montenegrin Government (“the Government”) were given notice of the application. THE FACTS 4. The applicants’ details and information relevant to the application are set out in the appended table. 5. The applicants complained of the non-enforcement of domestic decisions given against socially/State-owned companies. 6 . On 25 June 2019 the Constitutional Court found a violation of the applicants’ rights under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention on account of non-enforcement. The applicants were awarded 2,000 euros (EUR) each in non-pecuniary damage. 7 . In 2021, in the insolvency proceedings against a debtor, the insolvency administrator rendered decisions accepting the applicants’ claims. These decisions have not yet become final. 8 . The domestic decisions under consideration remain unenforced. THE LAW ALLEGED VIOLATION OF ARTICLE 6 § 1 OF THE CONVENTION AND OF ARTICLE 1 OF PROTOCOL No. 1 9. The applicants complained principally of the non-enforcement of domestic decisions given in their favour. They relied, expressly or in substance, on Article 6 § 1 of the Convention and on Article 1 of Protocol No. 1. 10 . The Government submitted that the applicants had failed to inform the Court about the insolvency administrator’s decisions (see paragraph 7 above) and invited it to reject the application as an abuse of the right of individual application in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 (a) and 4 of the Convention. 11. The Court reiterates that the execution of a judgment given by any court must be regarded as an integral part of a “hearing” for the purposes of Article 6. It also refers to its case-law concerning the non-enforcement or delayed enforcement of final domestic judgments (see Hornsby v. Greece , no. 18357/91, § 40, Reports of Judgments and Decisions 1997 ‑ II). 12. The Court further notes that the decisions in the present case ordered specific action to be taken. The Court therefore considers that the decisions in question constitute “possessions” within the meaning of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1. 13. In the leading cases of R. Kačapor and Others v. Serbia (nos. 2269/06 and 5 others, §§ 97-99, 106-16 and 119-20, 15 January 2008), and Mijanović v. Montenegro (no. 19580/06, §§ 81-91, 17 September 2013), the Court already found a violation in respect of issues similar to those in the present case. 14. Having examined all the material submitted to it, the Court has not found any fact or argument capable of persuading it to reach a different conclusion on the admissibility and merits of these complaints. In particular, as regards the Government’s argument (see paragraph 10 above), the Court notes that the insolvency administrator’s decisions have not yet become final and are thus not enforced. Therefore, the information in question did not concern the very core of the case as it is undisputed between the parties that the final decisions in the applicants’ favour under consideration remain unenforced (see paragraph 8 above). The Government’s objection must therefore be rejected. 15. Having regard to its case-law on the subject, the Court considers that in the instant case the authorities did not deploy all necessary efforts to enforce fully and in due time the decisions in the applicants’ favour. 16. These complaints are therefore admissible and disclose a breach of Article 6 § 1 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1. APPLICATION OF ARTICLE 41 OF THE CONVENTION 17. Regard being had to the documents in its possession and its own case ‑ law (see, in particular, R. Kačapor and Others , cited above , §§ 123-26; Stošić v. Serbia, no. 64931/10, §§ 66-68, 1 October 2013 ; and Mastilović and Others v. Montenegr o , no. 28754/10, § 52, 24 February 2022) the Court considers it reasonable not to award the applicants compensation in respect of non ‑ pecuniary damage because it has already been awarded domestically (see paragraph 6 above), but to award them a sum for costs and expenses indicated in the appended table. 18. The Court further notes that the respondent State has an outstanding obligation to enforce the judgments which remain enforceable. FOR THESE REASONS, THE COURT, UNANIMOUSLY, Declares the application admissible; Holds that this application discloses a breach of Article 6 § 1 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 concerning the non ‑ enforcement of domestic decisions given against socially/State-owned companies; Holds that the respondent State shall ensure, by appropriate means, within three months, the enforcement of the pending domestic decisions referred to in the appended table; Holds (a) that the respondent State is to pay the applicants, within three months, the amount indicated in the appended table in respect of costs and expenses, at the rate applicable at the date of settlement; (b) that from the expiry of the above-mentioned three months until settlement simple interest shall be payable on the above amount at a rate equal to the marginal lending rate of the European Central Bank during the default period plus three percentage points. Done in English, and notified in writing on 18 July 2024, pursuant to Rule 77 §§ 2 and 3 of the Rules of Court. Viktoriya Maradudina Péter Paczolay Deputy Registrar President APPENDIX Application raising complaints under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 (non-enforcement or delayed enforcement of domestic decisions given against socially/State-owned companies) The applicants are represented before the Court by Mr Ljubomir Marković, a lawyer practicing in Podgorica. Application no. Date of introduction Applicant’s name Year of birth Relevant domestic decision Start date of non-enforcement period End date of non-enforcement period Amount awarded for costs and expenses per application (in euros) [1] 55668/19 09/10/2019 (88 applicants) Miodrag ŽIVALJEVIĆ 1956 Milan ASANOVIĆ 1958 Gordana BAJIĆ 1968 Milorad BOGOJEVIĆ 1956 Vasilije BOLJEVIĆ 1946 Vasilije BOLJEVIĆ 1948 Branislav BOROVINIĆ 1947 Radenko BOŠKOVIĆ 1955 Goran BUBANJA 1968 Dragan BULATOVIĆ 1974 Mirko BULATOVIĆ 1967 Slavko CEKOVIĆ 1966 Zoran ČOVIĆ 1991 Miodrag ĆUPIĆ 1955 Zvezdana DABANOVIĆ 1947 Zef DEDIVANOVIĆ 1951 Đevad DELJANIN 1943 Milutin ĐOROJEVIĆ 1948 Milutin ĐUKANOVIĆ 1947 Zoran ĐUKANOVIĆ 1957 Miodrag DUMOVIĆ 1941 Golub GOLUBOVIĆ 1968 Vojka GOLUBOVIĆ 1945 Slavica GRGUROVIĆ 1960 Pero GRUJIĆ 1969 Bisera HAROVIĆ 1944 Željko ILIĆ 1955 Marinko IVANOVIĆ 1971 [2] Miloš IVANOVIĆ 1962 Radomir IVANOVIĆ 1976 Saveta IVANOVIĆ 1952 Radivoje JOVANOVIĆ 1946 Radomir JOVANOVIĆ 1958 Radovan JOVANOVIĆ 1956 Veselinka JUŠKOVIĆ 1949 Kosa KAŽIĆ 1963 Špiro KLIKOVAC 1947 Veseljko KLJAJIĆ 1967 Ilija KNEŽEVIĆ 1941 Vojko KNEŽEVIĆ 1941 Selman LJAČEVIĆ 1952 Stojanka MAKOČEVIĆ 1940 Milan MARAŠ 1958 Miodrag MARKOVIĆ 1957 Zlatko MARKOVIĆ 1985 Vjera MIJATOVIĆ 1952 Danilo MIKULIĆ 1940 Radovan MILOŠEVIĆ 1939 Milorad MIRANOVIĆ 1949 Biljana MITROVIĆ 1961 Bosa MUGOŠA 1946 Srđan NIKČEVIĆ 1968 Milenko NOVAKOVIĆ 1956 Željko NOVIĆEVIĆ 1971 Gojko PAJOVIĆ 1947 Radomir PAJOVIĆ 1948 Đon PALJAJ 1960 Milka PAVIĆEVIĆ 1963 Zoran PEJOVIĆ 1962 Velibor POLEKSIĆ 1954 Raško RADEVIĆ 1954 Milan RADINOVIĆ 1939 Miodrag RADINOVIĆ 1957 Nenad RADINOVIĆ 1957 Đorđije RADONJIĆ 1950 Mihailo RADOVIĆ 1938 Predrag RADULOVIĆ 1975 Vaso RADUNOVIĆ 1980 Ljubomir RAJOVIĆ 1952 Sado RAMOVIĆ 1955 Isah RASTODER 1954 Slobodanka RONDOVIĆ 1943 Izet ŠABOVIĆ 1982 Milan ŠALETIĆ 1968 Velimir ŠĆEPANOVIĆ 1942 Momo STIJEPOVIĆ 1952 Mirko STOJANOVIĆ 1966 Aco ŠUŠKAVČEVIĆ 1957 Mesudin TALJANOVIĆ 1966 Danilo TOMIĆ 1951 Bajram TUZOVIĆ 1954 Savo USKOKOVIĆ 1948 Nevena VUJAČIĆ 1963 Zorica VUJOŠEVIĆ 1951 Mirjana VUKOVIĆ 1966 Veselin VUKSANOVIĆ 1964 Predrag VULETIĆ 1952 Court of First Instance Podgorica, 29/10/2007 Court of First Instance Podgorica, 20/05/2009 Supreme Court 14/04/2009 Court of First Instance Podgorica, 20/05/2009 High Court Podgorica 05/05/2009 Court of First Instance Podgorica, 24/09/2007 High Court Podgorica 28/04/2009 Supreme Court 31/03/2009 Supreme Court 06/06/2009 Supreme Court 06/06/2009 High Court Podgorica 22/06/2009 High Court Podgorica 30/06/2009 High Court Podgorica 10/07/2009 Court of First Instance Podgorica 01/06/2009 Court of First Instance Podgorica 25/05/2009 Court of First Instance Podgorica 22/07/2009 Court of First Instance Podgorica 22/07/2009 Court of First Instance Podgorica 22/07/2009 Court of First Instance Podgorica 17/02/2009 Court of First Instance Podgorica 24/11/2009 Supreme Court 04/11/2009 Court of First Instance Podgorica 10/10/2009 Court of First Inst ancePodgorica 22/03/2010 Court of First Instance Podgorica 22/03/2010 Court of First Instance Podgorica 21/04/2009 Court of First Instance Podgorica 22/07/2009 Court of First Instance Podgorica 09/04/2010 Court of First Instance Podgorica 09/04/2010 Court of First Instance Podgorica 09/04/2010 Court of First Instance Podgorica 16/03/2010 Court of First Instance Podgorica 24/03/2010 Court of First Instance Podgorica 30/03/2010 Court of First Instance Podgorica 10/04/2007 Court of First Instance Podgorica 29/04/2010 Court of First Instance Podgorica 28/04/2010 Court of First Instance Podgorica 19/07/2010 Court of First Instance Podgorica 07/10/2010 Court of First Instance Podgorica 21/03/2011 Court of First Instance Podgorica 16/06/2011 Court of First Instance Podgorica 15/03/2010 High Court Podgorica 22/04/2010 Commercial Court 16/10/2017 Commercial Court 28/11/2017 16/05/2009 20/05/2009 04/06/2009 16/06/2009 16/06/2009 18/06/2009 19/06/2009 02/07/2009 02/07/2009 02/07/2009 22/07/2009 11/09/2009 16/09/2009 15/10/2009 09/11/2009 28/11/2009 02/12/2009 02/12/2009 24/12/2009 17/03/2010 07/04/2010 07/04/2010 10/04/2010 12/04/2010 12/04/2010 12/04/2010 12/04/2010 12/04/2010 12/04/2010 14/04/2010 12/05/2010 15/05/2010 17/05/2010 17/05/2010 27/05/2010 07/09/2010 08/03/2011 01/04/2011 23/06/2011 16/10/2017 12/05/2010 16/10/2017 28/11/2017 pending more than 15 years and 18 days pending more than 15 years and 14 days pending more than 15 years pending more than 14 years, 11 months and 18 days pending more than 14 years, 11 months and 18 days pending more than 14 years, 11 months and 16 days pending more than 14 years, 11 months and 15 days pending more than 14 years, 11 months and 1 day pending more than 14 years, 11 months and 1 day pending more than 14 years, 11 months and 1 day pending more than 14 years, 10 months and 12 days pending more than 14 years, 8 months and 23 days pending more than 14 years, 8 months and 18 days pending more than 14 years, 7 months and 19 days pending more than 14 years, 6 months and 25 days pending more than 14 years, 6 months and 6 days pending more than 14 years, 6 months and 1 day pending more than 14 years, 6 months and 1 day pending more than 14 years, 5 months and 10 days pending more than 14 years, 2 months and 17 days pending more than 14 years, 1 month and 27 days pending more than 14 years, 1 month and 27 days pending more than 14 years, 1 month and 24 days pending more than 14 years, 1 month and 22 days pending more than 14 years, 1 month and 22 days pending more than 14 years, 1 month and 22 days pending more than 14 years, 1 month and 22 days pending more than 14 years, 1 month and 22 days pending more than 14 years, 1 month and 22 days pending more than 14 years, 1 month and 20 days pending more than 14 years and 22 days pending more than 14 years and 19 days pending more than 14 years and 17 days pending more than 14 years and 17 days pending more than 14 years and 7 days pending more than 13 years, 8 months and 27 days pending more than 13 years, 2 months and 26 days pending more than 13 years, 2 months and 2 days pending more than 12 years, 10 months and 11 days pending more than 6 years, 7 months and 18 days pending more than 14 years and 22 days pending more than 6 years, 7 months and 18 days pending more than 6 years, 6 months and 6 days 250 [1] Plus any tax that may be chargeable to the applicants. [2] Rectified on 17 October 2024: the name of Mr Marko Ivanović was removed from the table.