Rechtsprechung / EGMR / 2017
EGMR Urteil vom 17.01.2017 – None
EuroparechtEU / InternationalVolltext
issued by the Registrar of the Court ECHR 015 (2017) 17.01.20 17 Judgments of 17 January 2017 The European Court of Human Rights has today notified in writing 31 judgments 1 : 15 Chamber judgments are summarised below; separate press releases have been issued for five other Chamber judgments in the cases of J. and Others v. Austria (application no. 58216/1 2), Gengoux v. Belgium (no. 76512/11), Habran and Dalem v. Belgium (nos. 43000/11 and 49380/11), Király and Dömötör v. Hungary (no. 10851/13), and A.H. and Others v. Russia (nos. 6033/13, 8927/13, 10549/13, 12275/13, 23890/13, 26309/13, 27161/13, 29197/13, 32224/13, 32331/13, 32351/13, 32368/13, 37173/13, 38490/13, 42340/13, and 42403/13); 11 Committee judgments, concerning issues which have already been submitted to the Court, can be consulted on Hudoc and do not appear in this press release. The judgments in French below are indicated with an asterisk (*). Gakharia v. Georgia (application no. 30459/13) The applicant, Revaz Gakharia, is a Georgian national who was born in 1966 and lives in Tbilisi. The case concerned decisions by the national courts restricting his parental rights, which had resulted in him losing contact with his daughter. Mr Gakharia’s daughter was born in 2000. She was mainly raised by her maternal grandmother in Georgia, both parents having left to work abroad. The relationship between the parents ended and Mr Gakharia’s former partner brought two sets of proceedings before the courts: the first in March 2008 for her daughter to be officially registered as resident at her address; and the second in December 2008 requesting that her daughter be issued with an international passport and allowed to leave Georgia without her father’s consent. There were three attempts during both sets of proceedings to serve summonses on Mr Gakharia at the address provided by the claimant party, each time without success. The courier noted that delivery had been impossible because the house was closed up and no one was living there. Information regarding the proceedings was therefore published in a daily newspaper, in accordance with the relevant domestic law in force at the time. The courts granted the applications in decisions taken in the absence of Mr Gakharia. In June 2012 Mr Gakharia, submitting that he had been in Russia and that he had only just learned about the decisions restricting his parental rights, sought to have both default decisions set aside. He complained in particular that the default proceedings had been unfair as he had not been properly summoned. He also claimed that his former partner had been fully aware of his whereabouts. However, both the first-instance court and the appeal court found that the procedure set out in domestic legislation for serving summonses had been observed. In particular, the courts had sent the summonses to the only available registered address and then, as serving the summonses had been unsuccessful, had made a public notification in a newspaper. 1 Under Articles 43 and 44 of the Convention, Chamber judgments are not final. During the three-month period following a Chamber judgment’s delivery, any party may request that the case be referred to the Grand Chamber of the Court. If such a request is made, a panel of five judges considers whether the case deserves further examination. In that event, the Grand Chamber will hear the case and deliver a final judgment. If the referral request is refused, the Chamber judgment will become final on that day. Under Article 28 of the Convention, judgments delivered by a Committee are final. Once a judgment becomes final, it is transmitted to the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe for supervision of its execution. Further information about the execution process can be found here: www.coe.int/t/dghl/mo nitoring/execution Relying in particular on Article 6 § 1 (right to a fair hearing/access to court) of the European Convention on Human Rights, Mr Gakharia complained that he had lost all contact with his daughter because of the two court decisions delivered in his absence. Violation of Article 6 § 1 Just satisfa ction : 1,500 euros (EUR) (non-pecuniary damage) Tsartsidze and Others v. Georgia (no. 18766/04) The applicants are 13 Georgian nationals who are all Jehovah’s Witnesses. The case concerned alleged harassment of Jehovah’s witnesses in Georgia. The applicants submitted that in 2000 and 2001 they had been the victims of various instances of intimidation and aggression towards Jehovah’s Witnesses either by Orthodox religious extremists or by the authorities, including the police. In five separate incidents some had been prevented from attending a religious meeting when stopped at a police checkpoint and others had had their religious meetings disrupted or had been stopped in the street by the police in possession of religious tracts; of those applicants some had been taken to police stations and had either been beaten or forced to sign a written undertaking not to hold any more gatherings in the future. All alleged that religious equipment and literature had been confiscated or stolen from them, and in one case had subsequently been publicly burned. The events described by six of the applicants in two of the incidents have been examined in a case already brought to the European Court of Human rights ( Begheluri and Others v. Georgia , no. 28490/02). All the applicants lodged administrative complaints against the Ministry of the Interior, police officers allegedly involved either directly or indirectly (on account of their failure to intervene in the various incidents) and the local authorities, claiming compensation. Their complaints were all later dismissed, ultimately at the level of the Supreme Court, because the police’s or the authorities’ involvement in the incidents had not been proven. The applicants essentially complained about the religiously motivated violence to which they had been subjected, alleging that it had breached their right to freely practise their religion via meetings and the distribution of religious literature. They relied in particular on Article 9 (freedom of thought, conscience and religion) and Article 14 (prohibition of discrimination) of the European Convention. Violation of Article 9 taken separately and in conjunction with Article 14 – with respect to Mr Mikirtumov, Mr Aliev, Mr Dzamukov, Mr Gabunia, Mr Gogelashvili, Mr Kurua, and Mr Chubinid ze. Just satisfa ction : EUR 500 jointly to Mr Gogelashvili, Mr Kurua and Mr Chubinidze in respect of pecuniary damage; EUR 1,500 each to Mr Mikirtumov, Mr Aliev, Mr Dzamukov, Mr Gabunia, Mr Gogelashvili, Mr Kurua and Mr Chubinidze in respect of non-pecuniary damage; and EUR 10,000 jointly to Mr Mikirtumov, Mr Aliev, Mr Dzamukov, Mr Gabunia, Mr Gogelashvili, Mr Kurua and Mr Chubinidze in respect of costs and expenses. Béres and Others v. Hungary (nos. 59588/12, 59632/12, and 59865/12) The applicants are 11 Hungarian nationals who were born between 1956 and 1988 and live in Budapest, Göd, and Dunakeszi (all in Hungary). The case concerned criminal proceedings brought against the applicants following their participation in a protest near the Parliament building in Budapes t. 2 Political activists, the applicants all participated in a demonstration on 23 December 2011 which involved them blocking the entrance to a car park next to the Parliament building by chaining themselves to each other and the gates. As a result, criminal proceedings were brought against them on charges of violation of personal liberty. However, in March 2012 the case against them was terminated at the pre-trial stage because they were amnestied under legislation enacted by Parliament. Shortly afterwards, six of the applicants lodged a constitutional complaint. They complained in particular that the wording of the Amnesty Act concerning the incident of December 2011 had used the expression “committed”, implying that they were guilty of having committed a criminal offence. The Constitutional Court declared their complaint inadmissible. It found that the wording of the Amnesty Act could not be interpreted as finding the applicants guilty of committing the crime with which they had been charged. Relying in particular on Article 6 § 2 (presumption of innocence), the applicants complained that the wording of the Amnesty Act had cast doubt on their innocence and damaged their reputation. No violation of Article 6 § 2 Jankovskis v. Lithuania (no. 21575/08) The applicant, Henrikas Jankovskis, is a Lithuanian national who was born in 1961. The case concerned his complaint that he had been refused Internet access in prison. In May 2006 Mr Jankovskis, serving a sentence in the Pravieniškės Correctional Home, wrote to the Ministry of Education and Science requesting information about the possibility of enrolling at university in order to acquire a degree in law. The Ministry wrote back to him, informing him that information about study programmes could be found on its website AIKOS. The prison authorities and subsequently the administrative courts all subsequently refused to grant Mr Jankovskis Internet access to this website, essentially referring to the legal ban on prisoners having Internet access (or the ban on prisoners’ telephone and radio communications and implicitly therefore also Internet) and security considerations. Relying on Article 10 (freedom of expression), Mr Jankovskis complained that not having Internet access in prison had prevented him from receiving information about a study programme. Violation of Article 10 Just satisfa ction : The Court held that the finding of a violation constituted in itself sufficient just satisfaction for the non-pecuniary damage sustained by Mr Jankovskis. Zybertowicz v. Poland (no. 59138/10) Zybertowicz v. Poland (no. 2) (no. 65937/11) The applicant, Andrzej Zybertowicz, is a Polish national who was born in 1954 and lives in Toru ń (Poland). He is a publicist and professor of sociology. Both cases concerned two separate sets of civil proceedings brought against him following interviews he had given or comments he had made to the media. A.M., a former dissident, leading Polish intellectual, and the editor-in-chief of Gazeta Wyborcza , one of Poland’s biggest daily newspapers, brought two civil actions – the first in April 2007 and the second in March 2008 – against Mr Zybertowicz requesting legal protection of his personal rights. A.M. requested in particular an apology for statements Mr Zybertowicz had made to the national daily, Rzeczpospo lita , about him in the context of the public debate on lustration of journalists. The so-called “lustration proceedings” in Poland aimed at exposing persons who had worked for or collaborated with the State’s security services during the communist period. 3 In the first set of proceedings Mr Zybertowicz argued before the domestic courts that his statement, referring to A.M.’s stay in prison during the communist era, had simply paraphrased A.M.’s views already given in numerous public declarations. In the second set of proceedings he argued that his statement, which referred to A.M. defending persons who had collaborated with the communist-era security services, had described A.M.’s position towards lustration in Poland. In both sets of proceedings the domestic courts examined the veracity of the statements and found that they were untrue, thus concluding that Mr Zybertowicz had breached A.M.’s personal rights. Ultimately, the Supreme Court either dismissed or refused to entertain Mr Zybertowicz’s cassation appeals in February 2010 and March 2011 respectively. In total he was ordered to pay approximately 4,760 euros to a charity and to arrange for apologies to be published in the Rzeczpospo lita . Relying on Article 10 (freedom of expression), he alleged that the domestic courts’ findings had infringed his right to freedom of expression. - case of Zybertow icz : Violation of Article 10 Just satisfa ction : EUR 3,915 (pecuniary damage), EUR 2,000 (non-pecuniary damage), and EUR 3,508 (costs and expenses) - case of Zybertowicz (no. 2) : No violation of Article 10 Tavares de Almeida Fernandes and Almeida Fernandes v. Portugal (no. 31566/13) The applicants, José Manuel Tavares de Almeida Fernandes and Maria Gabriela Neves Rebelo Cabrita Simão de Almeida Fernandes, were both born in 1957 and live in Colares (Portugal). They are husband and wife. The case concerned defamation proceedings brought against the couple by a judge . Mr Tavares de Almeida Fernandes is a well-known journalist in Portugal and was editor of the daily newspaper Público at the time in question. On 29 September 2006, Público published an editorial written by him entitled “The strategy of the spider” ( “A estratégia da aranha” ) about the election of Judge N.N. to President of the Supreme Court of Justice, which had taken place the previous day. In December 2007, Judge N.N. brought an action in the Lisbon Civil Court against the couple for defamation on the basis of that article, seeking 150,000 euros (EUR) in non-pecuniary damages. The court found in the judge’s favour, holding that the article had damaged Judge N.N.’s reputation. Mr Tavares de Almeida Fernandes was ordered to pay Judge N.N. EUR 35,000 in non-pecuniary damage. The court also held that Mrs Almeida Fernandes should not have been a party to the proceedin gs. Mr Tavares de Almeida Fernandes appealed the decision, arguing that it had breached his freedom of expression and should therefore be overturned. He further claimed that the compensation amount was too high. Judge N.N. also appealed on the basis that the award of damages was too low and that Mrs Almeida Fernandes should have been considered as a party to the proceedings. The Lisbon Court of Appeal upheld the first-instance judgment. It considered Mrs Almeida Fernandes to be a legitimate party to the proceedings (based on the fact that the applicants were married and that, as she had no independent income, her husband’s income directly benefited both of them) and ordered the couple to pay Judge N.N. EUR 60,000, plus interest, in compensation. The couple and Judge N.N. then lodged an appeal and a cross-appeal, respectively, in November 2010 with the Supreme Court of Justice. The Supreme Court refused to hear the couple’s appeal and 4 ordered that the case be remitted to the Lisbon Court of Appeal in order for it to correct its statement of facts. The Lisbon Court of Appeal delivered its new judgment in November 2012, upholding its previous judgment. Regarding the level of damages, the court again awarded EUR 60,000, noting that despite the offence the article had caused the judge, it had not proved an obstacle to his re-election by a large majority to the same post, and so had not damaged his professional f uture. Relying on Article 10 (freedom of expression), Mr Tavares de Almeida Fernandes and Mrs Almeida Fernandes complained that the Portuguese courts’ judgments had breached their freedom of expression and that the amount awarded to Judge N.N. as compensation for non-pecuniary damage had been disproportionate. Violation of Article 10 – as regards Mr Tavares de Almeida Fernandes Just satisfa ction : The Court held that the finding of a violation constituted in itself sufficient just satisfaction for the non-pecuniary damage sustained by Mr Tavares de Almeida Fernandes. It further awarded him EUR 9,400 for costs and expenses. Cacuci and S.C. Virra & Cont Pad S.R.L. v. Romania (no. 27153/07) The first applicant, Floare Cacuci, was born on 2 March 1939 and lives in Oradea. She is the owner and general manager of the second applicant, S.C. Virra & Cont Pad SRL, a single-member company based in Oradea. The case concerned the search of Ms Cacuci’s home and S.C. Virra’s business premises by the police. Ms Cacuci is an accounting expert, and wrote forensic accounting reports to be used in criminal cases. In October 2005, a criminal investigation was initiated against Ms Cacuci, on the suspicion that she had committed intellectual forgery while producing one of her reports in order to help one of the defendants avoid investigation. The Oradea District Court issued a warrant for the search of her home, with the aim of discovering evidence. According to Ms Cacuci, she was stopped by a police officer just after she left the house, who searched her bag and seized some personal documents. Officers then conducted a search of her home and her attached business premises (which were controlled by S.C. Virra). The authorities seized computer equipment, and a range of paper and electronic re cords. Ms Cacuci lodged a complaint with the prosecutor’s office in relation to the search and seizure, in addition to two sets of civil proceedings about the incident. All of her complaints and claims were dismissed. Ms Cacuci was eventually acquitted on all charges made against her. Relying on Article 8 (right to private life) the applicants complained in particular that the search of Ms Cacuci’s home and S.C. Virra’s business premises had infringed their rights to private life and correspondence, because they had been unnecessary, unlawful, and had involved the seizure of material which had no connection to the criminal charges. Relying on Article 13 (right to an effective remedy) taken in conjunction with Article 8, Ms Cacuci complained that Romanian law had not provided for an appeal against the decision allowing the home search. Violation of Article 8 – on account of the search performed on Ms Cacuci’s bag, which included the seizure of an orange notebook No violation of Article 8 – on account of the home search and the seizure of other various items on 21 October 2005 No violation of Article 13 taken in conjunction with Article 8 Just satisfa ction : EUR 4,500 (non-pecuniary damage) and EUR 500 (costs and expenses) 5 Revisi on Ciorcan and Others v. Romania (nos. 29414/09 and 44841/09) The applicants are 37 Romanian nationals of Roma origin born between 1937 and 1990. They all live in the Apalina neighbourhood in the town of Reghin (Romania). The case concerned the request for revision of a judgment of the European Court of Human Rights, relating to an incident on 7 September 2006 involving the police and the inhabitants of Apalina during which a large number of Roma had reportedly been injured and/or shot. Relying on Article 2 (right to life), seven of the applicants – the sons and daughters of one of the inhabitants of Apalina who had been shot in the stomach during the incident – complained that their mother’s life had been put in danger by the police’s use of excessive force, alleging that their mother had been shot with live ammunition and that the national authorities’ related investigation had been inadequate. All but three of the applicants also complained under Article 3 (prohibition of inhuman or degrading treatment) that they had been the victims of serious bodily harm, which had put their lives in danger, and that the authorities’ investigation into their allegations had been ineffective. Lastly, relying on Article 14 (prohibition of discrimination) in conjunction with Articles 2 and 3, the applicants all complained that prejudice and hostile attitudes towards Roma had played a decisive role in the police operation on 7 September 2006 – in particular the police’s excessive use of force – and in the inadequacy of the authorities’ ensuing investigations into the incident. In its judgment of 27 January 2015 the Court held that there had been a violation of Articles 2 and 3 of the Convention on account of the applicants’ ill-treatment by State officials and the subsequent failure to conduct an effective investigation into the events. The Court also found a violation of Article 14 in conjunction with Articles 2 and 3 of the Convention on account of the authorities’ failure to take all possible steps to investigate whether or not discrimination might have played a role in the events. The Court decided to award the applicants in respect of whom violations were found amounts varying between 6,000 and 7,500 euros (EUR) for non-pecuniary damage and dismissed the remainder of the claims for just satisfaction. The Government had now requested revision of the judgment of 27 January 2015, because one of the applicants, Susana Kalanyos, had died before the judgment was adopted. The Court decided to revise its judgment of 27 January 2015 in so far as it related to Ms Susana Kalanyos and to strike out the application in so far as it concerned her complaints. Pantea v. Romania (no 2) (no. 36525/07)* The applicant, Alexandru Pantea, is a Romanian national who was born in 1947 and lives in Zimnicea (Romania). A former prosecutor, Mr Pantea was practising as a lawyer at the time of the events. He complained of the length of the criminal proceedings against him. On 7 June 1994 the public prosecutor’s office at the Bihor County Court ordered the opening of criminal proceedings against Mr Pantea for causing bodily harm (see the judgment in Pante a v. Romania (no. 33343/96)). In a judgment of 19 June 2003 the Court of First Instance sentenced Mr Pantea to 262 days’ imprisonment for causing grievous bodily harm and ordered him to pay compensation to the injured party in respect of pecuniary and non-pecuniary damage. Mr Pantea appeale d. The case was subsequently examined by eight courts in three sets of proceedings. During the proceedings the County Court ruled that the applicant’s prosecution was time-barred. Consideration of the case was adjourned by the courts approximately 60 times, with over half of the requests for adjournment coming from Mr Pantea. In view of his numerous requests for adjournment, the courts found Mr Pantea’s conduct to be dilatory. Lastly, on 4 April 2007, a prosecutor from the Alba organised crime and terrorism investigation department informed the applicant, in accordance with 6 Article 91 § 5 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, that his telephone conversations had been intercepted by the competent authorities in the course of the proceedings against a group of people. Relying in particular on Article 6 § 1 (right to a fair trial within a reasonable time), Mr Pantea alleged that the length of the criminal proceedings against him had infringed the “reasonable time” principl e. Violation of Article 6 § 1 (length of proceedings) Just satisfa ction : EUR 900 (non-pecuniary damage) Revisi on Vidu and Others v. Romania (no. 9835/02)* The applicants, Hareta-Paraschiva Vidu, Matilda Zoescu and Adriana Popescu, were Romanian nationals who applied to the European Court of Human Rights on 14 January 2002. The case concerned a request for revision of a judgment of the European Court in relation to the failure to enforce a final judgment in the applicants’ favour. In its judgment on the merits of 21 February 2008 the Court found a violation of Article 6 § 1 (right to a fair hearing) and of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 (protection of property) on account of the failure to enforce a final District Court judgment of 22 May 1992 recognising the claimants as the owners of seven plots of land with a total surface area of 100,600 sq. m. As the original applicants died in the course of the proceedings, the Court noted in its judgment on the merits that the children of Hareta- Paraschiva Vidu, namely Ruxandra Vidu and Cristian Dragoş Vidu, had been the only heirs to express a wish to continue with the application, and therefore granted them the status of applicants. In its judgment of 10 June 2014 dealing with the question of just satisfaction (Article 41), the Court held that Romania was to ensure full enforcement of the final domestic judgment, failing which it would have to pay the applicants 230,000 euros (EUR) jointly in respect of pecuniary damage. The Court also awarded the applicants EUR 4,700 jointly in respect of non-pecuniary damage. On 10 April 2015 the Government informed the Court that they had learnt that the original applicants had already had possession and ownership of part of the land that had been the subject of the two judgments by the Court. They therefore requested that those judgments be revised within the meaning of Rule 80 of the Rules of Court and that the application be declared inadmissib le. The Court decided to revise its judgments of 21 February 2008 and 10 June 2014 and declared the application inadm issible. Barakhoyev v. Russia (no. 8516/08) The applicant, Sultan Abdul-Khalitovich Barakhoyev, now deceased, is a Russian national who was born in 1982 and lived in Kartsa, in the North Ossetia-Alania Republic (Russia). The case concerned his complaint about his arrest and ill-treatment in police custody. Mr Barakhoyev alleges that on 10 January 2007 he was stopped when walking down the street in Kartsa by a group of men in plain clothes, pushed into their car and taken to the local police station. He claims that he was then punched, kicked, suffocated with a plastic bag, beaten on his bare heels and had a grenade planted in the pocket of his jacket. The next day he was charged with illegally possessing a grenade and released pending investigation on the undertaking that he would not leave town. Mr Barakhoyev had sustained multiple bruises which were filmed on the day of his release by the lawyer retained by his parents to represent him and documented shortly afterwards by a forensic medical expert. 7 The Government contest Mr Barakhoyev’s version of events, submitting that he had been arrested on the basis of information received by the police that he was the leader of a group of young people of Ingush ethnic origin who had caused tensions with the Ossetian population in Kartsa and was in possession of illegal firearms. On arrival at the police station he had been examined by a doctor who found no injuries. The Government further contest Mr Barakhoyev’s allegation that he was ill- treated in police custody, and suggest that he must have sustained injuries when resisting arrest. The criminal proceedings brought against Mr Barakhoyev were discontinued in February 2007. The investigation into his allegations of ill-treatment, launched in February 2007, and discontinued and re-opened on several occasions with the regional prosecutor pointing out numerous defects in January 2015, is still ongoing. Relying on Article 3 (prohibition of inhuman and degrading treatment), Mr Barakhoyev complained that he had been ill-treated in police custody and that the ensuing investigation had been ineffective. He also relied on Article 5 (right to liberty and security), alleging that he had spent about 23 hours at the police station with no grounds for his arrest and in the absence of any reasonable suspicion that he had committed a crime. Violation of Article 3 (inhuman and degrading treatment) Violation of Article 3 (investigat ion) Violation of Article 5 § 1 Just satisfac tion : EUR 19,500 (non-pecuniary damage) and EUR 4,400 (costs and expenses) to Mr Barakhoyev’s mother B.K.M. Lojistik Tasimacilik Ticaret Limited Sirketi v. Slovenia (no. 42079/12) The applicant company, B.K.M. Lojistik Tasimacilik Ticaret Limited Sirketi, is a Turkish company based in Istanbul (Turkey). The company complained about the Slovenian authorities’ confiscation of its lorry . In November 2008 Slovenian customs officers found packages of suspected heroin when stopping the applicant company’s lorry while in transit. The driver, a Turkish citizen, was arrested, detained and charged with drug trafficking. The lorry was seized pending the decision in the case. When the driver was found guilty as charged in December 2008, the first-instance court ordered that the lorry be returned to the applicant company as it found that there was nothing to indicate that the applicant company had known about the transportation of illegal drugs on its lorry. However, on appeal by the prosecuting authorities, the Higher Court overturned this decision, finding that the relevant domestic legislation entailed mandatory confiscation of any vehicle used for drug trafficking, regardless of the owner’s good faith. The applicant company challenged the confiscation by lodging a constitutional complaint. However, the Constitutional Court dismissed the complaint, confirming the Higher Court’s view. Eventually, the lorry was put up for auction in 2009 and allegedly sold back to the applicant company. Relying on Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 (protection of property), the applicant company alleged that the confiscation of its lorry had been unlawful and disproportionate. Violation of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 Just satisfa ction : EUR 14,490 (pecuniary damage) and EUR 7,000 (costs and expenses) C.M. v. Switzerland (no. 7318/09)* The applicant, C.M., is a Swiss national who was born in 1945 and lives in Zug (Switzerland). The case concerned the proceedings relating to C.M.’s disability pension. 8 In May 2001 the Social Insurance Tribunal ordered the pension fund to pay C.M. retroactive disability benefits dating back to 11 June 1993. In August 2003 C.M. was informed of the amount of his disability pension and of the arrears, including interest. In December 2003 C.M. brought an action in the Social Insurance Tribunal against the pension fund, seeking recalculation of the interest. He subsequently signed an out-of-court settlement and withdrew the action. In September 2007 C.M. brought a fresh action against the pension fund seeking a full disability pension with effect from 11 June 1993 and the payment of 5% interest on the arrears with effect from 11 June 1998. The pension fund, in its written reply of 19 December 2007, requested that the action be dismissed, referring to the out-of-court settlement. In March 2008 the Social Insurance Tribunal dismissed C.M.’s claims. He appealed against that decision, arguing in particular that he had been unable to submit his observations in reply to those of the pension fund submitted on 19 October 2007, as he had not received them until 10 March 2008, two days before delivery of the Social Insurance Tribunal’s judgment of 12 March 2008. Relying in particular on Article 6 § 1 (right to a fair hearing), C.M. notably complained that the Social Insurance Tribunal had not sent him the observations of the opposing party concerning his action until a few days before judgment had been given, with the result that he had been unable to reply to them . Violation of Article 6 § 1 Just satisfa ction : EUR 4,000 (costs and expenses) Önkol v. Turkey (no. 24359/10)* The applicants, Raif Önkol and Saliha Önkol, are Turkish nationals who were born in 1960 and 1956 respectively and live in Diyarbakır (Turkey). The case concerned the death of Ceylan Önkol, Mr and Mrs Önkol’s daughter, after an explosive device had blown up in a field where she had been grazing livestoc k. On 28 September 2009 twelve-year-old Ceylan Önkol was killed when an explosive device blew up in a field near the village of Şenlik. Her body was taken to the gendarmerie station by her parents and some of the villagers so that a medical examination could be carried out, as the authorities had not gone to the scene on the day of the explosion because the site was considered a terrorist risk. On 30 September 2009 the public prosecutor’s office issued a site inspection report. On the same day the Criminal Court ordered that the investigation be kept confidential. That order was lifted on 15 October 2009 at the public prosecutor’s request. The criminal investigation established, among other findings, that the military authorities had not carried out any operations at the scene of the explosion on the day of the incident or beforehand, and that there was no evidence to suggest that the type of device that had killed Ceylan Önkol had been used by the security forces during the 12 clashes that had taken place in the region between the security forces and members of a terrorist organisation. In April 2014 the public prosecutor’s office issued a permanent search warrant aimed at identifying the perpetrators before the prosecution became time-barred. The security forces continued their search and drew up quarterly reports. Meanwhile, Mr and Mrs Önkol applied to the Ministry of Defence for compensation on account of their daughter’s death, but no action was taken. In 2010 they brought an action in the Diyarba kır Administrative Court seeking compensation for the damage caused by their daughter’s death. In September 2014 the court awarded them a sum of approximately 10,000 euros (EUR), plus default interest, on the basis of the State’s strict liability. Mr and Mrs Önkol lodged an appeal on points of law which is currently pending before the Supreme Administrative Court. 9 Relying in particular on Article 2 (right to life) Mr and Mrs Önkol complained about the death of their daughter and the lack of an effective investigation. No violation of Article 2 (right to life and investigation) This press release is a document produced by the Registry. It does not bind the Court. Decisions, judgments and further information about the Court can be found on www.echr.coe.int. To receive the Court’s press releases, please subscribe here: www.echr.coe.int /RSS/en or follow us on Twitter @ECHR_P ress . Press contacts echrpress@echr. coe.int | tel: +33 3 90 21 42 08 Tracey Turner-Tretz (tel: + 33 3 88 41 35 30) Denis Lambert (tel: + 33 3 90 21 41 09) Inci Ertekin (tel: + 33 3 90 21 55 30) George Stafford (tel: + 33 3 90 21 41 71) The European Court of Human Rights was set up in Strasbourg by the Council of Europe Member States in 1959 to deal with alleged violations of the 1950 European Convention on Human Rights. 10